Date / Jurisdiction Caption Statement of Case Result R&R Attorney 12/29/2006 7th Appellate Dist. Thompson v. Eroglu Affirming summary judgment in favor of Defendants insurance company since insurance coverage was properly canceled prior to accident involving motorcycle and tractor-trailer Affirmed Brian D. Sullivan 12/20/2006 Cuyahoga M. Witzke v. S. Pathroff Defense of auto liability personal injury claim. Plaintiff verdict 12/20/2006 Supreme Court of Ohio Glidden Co. v. Lumbermens Mut. Cas. Co. Reversing denial of insurer's motion for summary judgment since insurance coverage did not extend to purchasers of a paint business in regard to underlying lead-based paint actions. Reversed Holly Marie Wilson 12/18/2006 USDC No. Dist. of Ohio E/O Brumfield v. Tyson Foods Defense of wrongful death and multiple injury catastrophic trucking liability claim. Plaintiff verdict Kenneth P. Abbarno Robert S. Yallech 12/18/2006 Hardin E/O Ilo Carter v. L. Norris, M.D. Defense of medical malpractice wrongful death claim based on alleged surgical negligence in conducting a biopsy for gastric legion. Defense verdict Jeanne M. Mullin 12/18/2006 Hardin E/O Ilo Carter v. J. Newhouser, M.D. Defense of wrongful death medical malpractice claim for alleged mismanaged post-operative care. Defense verdict Donald J. Moracz 12/15/2006 Richland E/O Haycook v. S. Toward, M.D. Defense of medical malpractice wrongful death claim. Defense verdict Michael Romanello Matthew L. Schrader 12/15/2006 Warren S. Kushnir v. FedEx Freight East, Inc. Defense of trucking liability personal injury claim. Plaintiff verdict Robert W. Hojnoski 12/13/2006 Cuyahoga J. Kawa v. D. DeVor DDS Arbitration defense of dental malpractice claim. Finding for Defendant Richard J. Rymond 12/13/2006 Scioto E/O R. Henderson v. R. Tan, M.D. Defense of medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict William A. Meadows Rick L. Weil 12/07/2006 Mahoning Hazimihalis v. Boniface, M.D. Defense of orthopedic medical malpractice case. Defense verdict Kelly Johns Robert D. Warner 12/06/2006 Summit A. Whatley v. M. Porter Prosecution of plaintiff auto liability personal injury claim. Plaintiff verdict John B. Stalzer 12/06/2006 Clark B. Johnson v. T. Rak, M.D. Defense of plastic surgery medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Warren M. Enders 12/05/2006 Allen E/O Stevens v. Wisser M.D., et al. Defense of cardiology medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Donald J. Moracz 12/05/2006 Franklin S. Schumer v. L. Love, M.D. Defense of medical malpractice claim against opthalmologist involving retinal detachment. Defense verdict 12/01/2006 11th Appellate Dist. Dalejo Farm, Inc. v. Approved Statewide Title Agency Corp. Affirming summary judgment of Plaintiffs breach of contract claims in favor of Defendant Affirmed Martin T. Galvin 11/30/2006 Pickway Williamson v. Scioto Township Defense of governmental zoning liability claim for declaratory judgment action and damages Zoning allowed but damages denied Paul Garinger 11/29/2006 U.S. Court of Appeals - Sixth Circuit Preferred Capital, Inc. v. Aetna Maintenance, Inc. Reversing appellate courts grant of lessees' motion to dismiss since clause in equipment lease requiring that disputes regarding assignment be governed by the laws of the state of incorporation of the assignee was valid and enforceable Reversed Clifford C. Masch Holly Marie Wilson 11/27/2006 Franklin City of Columbus, et al. v. Large Cartage, Inc. Defense of trucking liability property damage and personal injury claim. Defense verdict Michael J. Valentine 11/27/2006 Franklin A. Thomas v. J. J. Kennedy Defense of admitted auto liability personal injury claim. Plaintiff verdict 11/20/2006 Licking D. Dick v. Tad Tool & Dye Co. Prosecution of employer intentional tort case. Plaintiff verdict Paulette Ivan D. Patrick Kasson 11/15/2006 Supreme Court of Ohio Rose v. Garfield Hts. Denying discretionary review of appellate courts reversal of summary judgment granted to Defendant where Police Officer sought uninsured motorist (UM) coverage from city's insurer for hit-and-run accident Case Dismissed 11/10/2006 Lake S. Lanzone v. Lake Hospital System Defense of hospital malpractice claim alleging contribution to birth trauma injury by inadequate staffing and regulations. Defense verdict Marilena DiSilvio 11/10/2006 Lake S. Lanzone v. J. Zart, M.D. Defense of birth trauma obstetrical medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Ronald A. Mingus 11/03/2006 Miami Stephenson v. Upper Valley Family Care Defense of medical malpractice failure to diagnose claim. Plaintiff verdict Brian D. Goldwasser Rick L. Weil 11/02/2006 Cuyahoga P. Hodnick v. Ameriprise Auto & Home Ins. Co. Arbitration defense of auto liability personal injury claim. Finding for Defendant 11/02/2006 USDC Dayton, OH E/O Zachary v. ICON Fitness & Health, Inc. Defense of products liability wrongful death case. Defense verdict Hugh J. Bode Robert S. Yallech 11/02/2006 8th Appellate Dist. Patitucci v. McNeal Schick Archibald & Biro Affirming directed verdict in a legal malpractice claim because attorney did not have a duty to advise appellant on matters outside the scope of his representation Affirmed Clifford C. Masch 11/01/2006 Franklin Orville v. Waste Management of Ohio, Inc, Arbitrationdefense of auto liability personal injury claim. Finding for claimant Paul Garinger 11/01/2006 Warren, KY Helton v. Tarter Gate Co. Defense of alleged defective livestock gate and fencing system resulting in escape of domesticated animals causing automobile crash resulting in catastrophic injuries. Plaintiff verdict Brian D. Goldwasser 10/26/2006 Mahoning B. Bevilacqua v. Marx, M.D. Defense of surgical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Thomas A. Prislipsky Kelly Johns 10/26/2006 Stark T. Miller v. R. Beighley Prosecution of plaintiff auto liability personal injury case. Plaintiff verdict Andrew Jamison 10/20/2006 Cuyahoga E/O Savoca v. H. Shaw, M.D. Defense of wrongful death of 50-year old male claiming emergency room medical negligence. Defense verdict Marilena DiSilvio Stephen E. Walters 10/20/2006 Cuyahoga DeCarlo v. MacDowell Prosecution of plaintiff frivolous litigation and abuse of process claim. Plaintiff verdict Adam M. Fried Bethanie E. Ricketts 10/19/2006 Summit D. Artrip v. Wadsworth Rittman Hospital Defense of physical therapy services medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Stephan C. Kremer 10/19/2006 8th Appellate Dist. Sesko v. Caw Affirming summary judgment in favor of Defendant insurance company because Plaintiff failed to provide timely notice and the policy did not cover a loss based upon disability benefits. Affirmed Michelle J. Sheehan 10/13/2006 Montgomery M. Smith v. Global Executive Mortgage Defense of creditor liability claim under Mortgage Broker Act. Plaintiff verdict Gregory D. Brunton 10/07/2006 Jefferson P. Carducci v. J. Culp M.D. Defense of medical malpractice infectious disease claim. Defense verdict Thomas A. Prislipsky 10/04/2006 Lucas E/O Revilla v. E. Shea, M.D. Defense of wrongful death internal medicine malpractice claim. Favorable Result Justin D. Harris Donald J. Moracz 09/29/2006 Cuyahoga D. Szerszen v. Fed Ex Freight East Inc. Defense of workers' compensation claim in alleging multiple lumbar disc conditions. Defense verdict Charles P. Alusheff 09/29/2006 Trumbull Hasting Mutual Ins. Co. v. Pass & Seymour Defense of fire property damage liability claim. Defense verdict Kenneth P. Abbarno 09/29/2006 Erie McKenzie v. Schmidt M.D. Defense of admitted liability medical malpractice claims. Plaintiff verdict Thomas B. Kilbane 09/28/2006 8th Appellate Dist. Jacob v. Fadel Affirming summary judgment in favor of Defendant Executor since Plaintiff failed to establish a claim as a result of eviction during probate process Affirmed Martin T. Galvin 09/28/2006 10th Appellate Dist. Bright v. Family Medicine Found. Inc. Affirming denial of Defendants motions to vacate default judgment rendered in favor of Plaintiff in her malpractice action. Affirmed 09/26/2006 Hamilton R. Coleman v. Dragon City Chinese Restaurant Arbitration defense of commercial restaurant premises liability for personal injury from claim of adulterated food. Finding for Defendant John Dunn 09/25/2006 Hamilton D. Chatman v. Frisch Restaurants, Inc. Arbitration defense of commercial restaurant premises claiming personal injury from adulterated food claim. Finding for defendant John Dunn 09/21/2006 8th Appellate Dist. Bambeck v. Cathlioc Dioceses of Cleveland Affirming summary judgment in favor of Defendant since there was no contract for electrical services performed at parish festival Affirmed Martin T. Galvin 09/20/2006 Hamilton Municipal C. Brewster v. SuperValue dba Biggs Arbitration defense of commercial premises liabliity personal injury claim. Finding for Defendant Danny M. Newman Jr. 09/20/2006 9th Appellate Dist. Galland v. Meridia Health Sys. Inc. Affirming summary judgment in favor of Defendant in claim for negligent infliction of emotional distress where the young Plaintiff stepped on a contaminated suture needle while at medical facility but was not able to comprehend any fear Affirmed Holly Marie Wilson 09/19/2006 10th Appellate Dist. Kinsey v. Erie Ins. Group Affirming summary judgment in favor of Defendant insurance company since Plaintiff was not entitled to underinsured motorist coverage Affirmed 09/13/2006 Supreme Court of Ohio Sheaffer v. Westfield Ins. Co. Affirming appellate court's judgment sine under law -of-the-case doctrine, the denial of jurisdiction over a discretionary appeal by the Supreme Court of Ohio settles the issue of law appealed such that a lower court cannot retrospectively apply a Affirmed 09/11/2006 CCCP M. Faulhaber v. M. Binder M.D. Defense of plastic surgical medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Brian T. Gannon 09/07/2006 Geauga J. DiCarro v. R. Mendeszoon DPM Defense of podiatric malpractice claim. Defense verdict Thomas B. Kilbane Bethanie E. Ricketts 09/05/2006 U.S. Court of Appeals - Sixth Circuit Curry v. Bulk Transport, Inc. Remanding with instructions since diversity jurisdiction was destroyed when non- diverse parties were named Defendant is suit involving warehouse manager injured when a truck carrying potassium sulfate overturned. Remanded for lack of jurisdiction Brian D. Sullivan 09/02/2006 Geauga Cunningham v. Brown Arbitration defense of dental malpractice claim. Defense verdict Ronald A. Mingus 08/21/2006 12th Appellate Dist Land O'Lakes, Inc. v. Nationwide Tanks, Inc. Reversing summary judgment granted in favor of Plaintiff's subrogation claim because of material issues regarding contributory negligence where a tank carrying liquid fertilizer ruptured, contaminating nearby fields and streams Reversed Martin T. Galvin 08/18/2006 Cuyahoga M. Porter v. T. Sidor M.D. Defense of wrongful death medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Brian T. Gannon William A. Meadows 08/17/2006 Franklin J. Lin v. M. Lautner Defense of auto liability personal injury claim. Plaintiff verdict 08/15/2006 USDC WP Hickman v. St. Clair, Esq. Defense of legal malpractice fraud and conspiracy claim. Defense verdict James J. Brudny, Jr Paul-Michael La Fayette 08/15/2006 CCCP B. Och v. G. Saridakis, M.D. Defense of pediatric medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Thomas A. Prislipsky 08/14/2006 Lorain J. Macken v. Wickens Herzer Panza Defense of legal malpractice conspiracy and fraud claim. Defense verdict James P. Sammon 08/10/2006 Hamilton Knapp v. Saunders, et al. Defense of homeowners premises liability personal injury claim. Defense verdict 08/08/2006 Cuyahoga Stewart v. M.R.I. Defense of intellectual property and commercial dispute involving franchise operation. Defense verdict Roy A. Hulme 08/07/2006 Mahoning M. Roloson, Guardian of Eric Roloson v. D. Cestrone Defense of catastrophic medical malpractice claim. Settled Kenneth P. Abbarno 08/07/2006 Portage Baker v. Pat Boyle Realty Co. Defense of real estate agent E&O claim. Plaintiff verdict Cynthia A. Lammert 08/04/2006 6th Appellate Dist Hartman v. Schachner Affirming award of prejudgment interest against Defendant for misdiagnosis of tumor in Plaintiffs ear. Affirmed Martin T. Galvin 08/03/2006 Mahoning J. Garcher et al. v. J. Botsko, M.D. Defense of family practice medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Stephan C. Kremer Thomas A. Prislipsky 07/31/2006 Lucas T. Rayford v. Westgate Ltd. Partnership aka Clarion Hotel Toledo Arbitration defense of commercial premises property damages liability claim. Finding for Defendant Emily W. Newman 07/27/2006 Butler Sellers v. L&S Sports, Inc. Defense of intellectual property trade association injunctive action. Injunction denied Joseph Borchelt 07/26/2006 Montgomery Adkins v. Anderson Austin News Defense of employer intentional tort claim. Defense verdict B Scott Jones 07/25/2006 Cuyahoga Greene v. Veal Defense of auto liability personal injury claim. Defense verdict Michael P. Gilbride 07/21/2006 Cuyahoga McFadden v. South Pointe Hospital Defense of hospital malpractice claim. Settled during trial for pretrial offer Erin Siebenhar Hess Ronald A. Mingus 07/21/2006 Cuyahoga E/O Holman v. Kates M.D. and Cleveland Physicians Inc. Defense of medical malpractice delayed diagnosis claim. Defense verdict Thomas B. Kilbane 07/14/2006 Hamilton S. Ward v. K. Cooke Arbitration defense of auto liability personal injury claim. Award to Plaintiff Thomas B. Kilbane 07/14/2006 Defiance J. Coffey v. Dollar General Defense of workers' compensation psychiatric allowability claim. Plaintiff verdict Ronald A. Fresco 07/13/2006 8th Appellate Dist. Cohen v. Meridia Health Systems Affirming summary judgment in favor of Defendant healthcare provider where patient brought suit after she cut her leg on a chair in an aisle while maneuvering her electric wheelchair at the facility. Affirmed Michelle J. Sheehan 07/10/2006 Hamilton L. Jause v. Aimco Arbitration defense of property damage landlord liability case. Finding for Defendant Vincent P. Antaki 07/07/2006 Geauga J. Dicarro v. M. Mendeszoon, DPM Defense of podiatric medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Thomas B. Kilbane Bethanie E. Ricketts 07/05/2006 Hamilton Johnson v. Continental Casualty Defense of adulterated food claim. Defense verdict John Dunn 07/05/2006 Franklin Shambaugh v. Liberty Mutual Arbitration defense of UM liability. Award to plaintiff Kevin P. Foley 07/03/2006 Stark E/O J. Hershey v. J. Casanova M.D. Defense of medical malpractice wrongful death claim. Defense verdict Thomas A. Prislipsky 06/30/2006 Cuyahoga G. Sevelli v. M. Sheehan, M.D. Defense of medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Thomas B. Kilbane 06/29/2006 Stark M. Robinson v. D. Smith Defense of admitted liabilty legal malpractice claim. Award to plaintiff W. Bradford Longbrake 06/26/2006 Highland Nelson v. Dollar General Arbitration defense of personal injury commercial premises liability claim. Finding for defendant Paul Garinger 06/21/2006 Cuyahoga E. Smith v. C. Scott, M.D. Defense of emergency medicine medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Kenneth P. Abbarno 06/21/2006 Cuyahoga E. Smith v. H. Gatha, M.D. Defense of internal medicine medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Robert D. Warner 06/20/2006 Cuyahoga R. Jones v. Express Carriers Arbitration defense of admitted trucking liability personal injury claim. Award to plaintiff Brian M. Zaber 06/20/2006 Cuyahoga L. Reed v. Express Carrier Inc. Arbitration defense of admitted trucking liabilty personal injury claim. Award to plaintiff Brian M. Zaber 06/19/2006 Stark K. Foss v. T. Watson M.D. Defense of orthopedic surgery medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Stephan C. Kremer 06/19/2006 Butler W. Muller v. Q West Communications International Inc. Arbitration defense of admitted auto liability personal injury claim. Judgment for Plaintiff John Dunn 06/12/2006 Cuyahoga E/O Schilling v. T. Slawinski M.D. Defense of wrongful death surgical medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Christine S. Reid 06/12/2006 Cuyahoga E/O Schilling v. K. Szeto M.D. Defense of wrongful death medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Erin Siebenhar Hess Stephen E. Walters 06/08/2006 Lake Parker v. Lake Hospital System Defense of hospital liability/physical therapy services malpractice claim. Defense verdict 06/06/2006 Summit MacDowell v. DeCarlo Defense of probate litigation to set aside beneficiary's assets. Finding for Defendant Adam M. Fried Bethanie E. Ricketts 06/02/2006 2nd Appellate Dist. Dunina v. LifeCare Hospitals of Dayton Affirming summary judgment in favor of Defendant where Plaintiff nurse brought breach of contract and various tort claims after she was removed from assignments upon unsubstantiated suspicion of stealing drugs. Affirmed 05/25/2006 Lucas T. Friedman and National Technologies v. People's Banking Co. and B. Jackson Defense of banking officer E&O claim arising out of defaulted loan. Defense verdict Laurie J. Avery 05/24/2006 Cuyahoga Watson v. Metro Medical Center Defense of catastrophic obstetrical and birth injury case. Defense verdict James L. Malone 05/23/2006 Cuyahoga Atkins v Dupont Prosecution of plaintiff defamation claim. Defense verdict Martin T. Galvin Robert S. Yallech 05/22/2006 Wayne E/O Jvorsky v. Milton Township Defense of wrongful death governmental liability claim involving railroad crossing fatal accident. Defense verdict Brian D. Sullivan 05/22/2006 Cuyahoga Buernaoer v. Progressive Insurance Co. Prosecution of personal injury auto liability claim. Plaintiff verdict 05/19/2006 Hamilton Shepard v. Star Personnel Services Defense of defamation intentional tort claim. Plaintiff verdict Danny M. Newman Jr. 05/19/2006 Franklin R. Gray v. J. Mayo, M.D. Defense of medical malpractice claim for prescription drug addiction and permanent deficits. Hung jury Lisa House Michael Romanello 05/18/2006 8th Appellate Dist Czarney v. Porter Reversing directed verdict in favor of hospital association in wrongful death suit since there was not necessarily an intervening cause of death and nurses may have been negligent for failing to follow physician's direct orders. Reversed Michelle J. Sheehan 05/17/2006 Hamilton R. Burns v. Columbia Casualty Co. Defense of auto liability personal injury claim. Defense verdict John Dunn Robert W. Hojnoski 05/17/2006 Supreme Court of Ohio Sharonville v. Am. Emps. Ins. Co. Affirming appellate court's decision that summary judgment in favor of general liability insurers was appropriate, but was in appropriate in relation to law-enforcement liability insurers. Affirmed Clifford C. Masch Holly Marie Wilson 05/17/2006 Supreme Court of Ohio In re Guardianship of Peck Dismissing as improper a nunc pro tunc order in regard to incompetence and guardianship of a ward. Case Dismissed Brian D. Sullivan Holly Marie Wilson 05/15/2006 Cuyahoga Cochran v. Donzi Marine, Inc. Defense of boat manufacturer product liability claim. Defense verdict Michael P. Gilbride Justin D. Harris 05/12/2006 Hamilton Works v. Wal-Mart Arbitration defense of invasion of privacy, intentional tort claim. Award to Defendant Thomas B. Kilbane 05/12/2006 Pike Copeland v. Hudson M.D. Defense of cryosurgery medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Robert Kish 05/10/2006 Supreme Court of Ohio Smith v. Conley Reversing lower courts ruling on when the statute of limitations begins to run in a legal malpractice claim. Reversed Clifford C. Masch Holly Marie Wilson 05/08/2006 Lake E/O Poelella v. Kotak, M.D. Defense of wrongful death medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Erin Siebenhar Hess Stephen E. Walters 05/04/2006 8th Appellate Dist. Rodriguez v. Rockefeller Bldg Assoc. Reversing summary judgment granted to Defendant in premises liability case because there were fact questions regarding whether defect which resulted in injuries sustained by business invitee were open and obvious Reversed Holly Marie Wilson 05/02/2006 Cuyahoga E/O Franzone v. Hillcrest Hospital Defense of wrongful death medical malpractice claim. Plaintiff verdict Kenneth P. Abbarno 05/01/2006 Columbiana M. Zigler v. Allstate Ins. Co. Prosecution of plaintiff automobile personal injury action. Plaintiff verdict 04/28/2006 Cuyahoga Frankhauser v. Cirino Defense of mecical malpractice failure to diagnose wrongful. Defense verdict Thomas B. Kilbane Bethanie E. Ricketts 04/27/2006 Franklin Zanke v. Village Green Apartments Defense of commercial premises liabilty claim. Plaintiff verdict Michael J. Valentine 04/18/2006 Hamilton Patel v. B. Gerla, Esq. Arbitration defense of legal malpractice claim. Award for Plaintiff Joseph Borchelt Brian D. Goldwasser 04/12/2006 Franklin R. Smith v. Lane Alton & Horst Defense of workers' compensation claim against law firm involving administrative chargebacks. Finding for Defendant Ronald A. Fresco 04/11/2006 Hamilton N. Babcock v. R. Um, DMD & Family Dental Care Defense of catastrophic dental malpractice case. Defense verdict Brian D. Goldwasser 04/11/2006 Montgomery Trustees of Montgomery County v. Edaw Architects, Inc. & PEM Fountains Defense of defective design and manufacturing products liabilty property damage claim. Defense verdict Hugh J. Bode 04/07/2006 Cuyahoga K. Hubbard v. North Shore Auto (J. D. Byrider) Defense of employment practices racial discrimination claim. Settlement during trial Gregory G. Guice Roy A. Hulme 04/06/2006 8th Appellate Dist Abrams v. Siegel Affirming verdict in favor of Plaintiff (doctor) since evidence supported inference that Defendant (doctor) violated contractual agreements in regard to employment. Affirmed Clifford C. Masch 04/04/2006 Cuyahoga Scott v. W. 130th Wrecking Arbitration defense of property damage trucking liability claim. Finding for Defendant John B. Stalzer 04/04/2006 Cuyahoga Johnson v. XL Express Arbitration defense of trucking liabilty property damage claim. Finding for defendant Brian M. Zaber 03/31/2006 Hamilton E/O K. Marriott v. Eastgate Nursing Home of Cincinnati Healthcare Defense of nursing home liability case. Defense verdict Danny M. Newman Jr. Rick L. Weil 03/31/2006 Bedford J. Santiago v. Keystone Freight Inc. Arbitration defense of trucking liability property damage claim. Finding for claimant Brian M. Zaber 03/31/2006 Cuyahoga Ruggeri v. Smith, M.D. Defense of dental and medical malpractice case involving maxofacial surgery. Defense verdict Richard J. Rymond 03/30/2006 Cuyahoga Northern Ohio Food Terminal v. Granger Construction Co. Prosecution of commercial litigation injunctive action for nuisance. Judgment for Plaintiff granting injunctive relief. Joseph Borchelt Daniel R. Haude 03/30/2006 Miami E/O Bundy v. Schwans Defense of wrongful death trucking liability claim. Defense verdict Michael J. Valentine 03/29/2006 Cuyahoga E/O Adkins v. J. Weitecha, M.D. Defense of wrongful death endocrinologist medical malpractice claim. Defense verdict Christine S. Reid 03/29/2006 Cuyahoga E/O Adkins v. L. Stallings M.D. Defense of wrongful death medical malpractice claim of misdiagnosis. Defense verdict Anthony M. Catanzarite John P. O’Neil 03/27/2006 Summit Nationwide v. Waste Management Arbitration defense of trucking liability property damage claim. Finding for Defendant Andrew Jamison 03/23/2006 Lucas J. Lord v. Fed Ex Freight Defense of workers' compensation claim for chronic pain and herniated disc condition for additional allowance. Defense verdict Philip S. Heebsh Shelby M. McMillan 03/23/2006 Cuyahoga A. Scott v. W. 130th Street Auto Wrecking Arbitration defense of property damage trucking liability claim. Finding for Defendant John B. Stalzer 03/23/2006 Kentucky Blevins v. Abderdeen Home Inspection Arbitration defense of professional liability home inspector E&O claim. Finding for Defendant B Scott Jones 03/23/2006 Franklin A. Stolzenbach v. J. Schanzenbach Defense of Internet technology dispute in claim for injunctive relief. Judgment for Defendant Gregory D. Brunton 03/23/2006 8th Appellate Dist Jackson-Summers v. Brooks Affirming summary judgment in favor of Defendant since Plaintiff failed to use expert testimony to establish a prima facie claim of medical malpractice Affirmed Martin T. Galvin Holly Marie Wilson 03/16/2006 8th Appellate Dist Yessenow v. Aue Design Studio Inc. Reversing trial courts denial of motion to compel arbitration in breach of contract suit since trial court did not hold a determination as to the validity of the arbitration clause. Reversed Holly Marie Wilson 03/15/2006 Hamilton B. McKenna v. CJ Hughes Construction Co. Arbitration defense of property damage construction liability case. Finding for Defendant Thomas B. Kilbane 03/06/2006 Stark L&M of Stark County v. LaDanos Footwear Prosecution of commercial nuisance and damage case by landlord against tenant. Defense verdict 03/03/2006 Cuyahoga Salamone v. Schawnik Prosecution of plaintiff personal injury auto liability claim. Plaintiff verdict Anthony M. Catanzarite 02/28/2006 Hamilton Larsen v. Seven Hills Development Arbitration defense of commercial premises liability claim. Judgment for Defendant John Dunn 02/24/2006 U.S. Court of Appeals - Sixth Circuit Parker Hannifin Corp v. Dayco Prods. LLC Affirming trial courts finding that the asset purchase agreement between the parties did not make the purchaser liable for product liability claims relating to a line of business discontinued years before agreement was made. Affirmed Holly Marie Wilson 02/21/2006 Cuyahoga Doster v. Carillo, M.D. Defense of general surgeon medical malpractice claim. Settlement during trial Kenneth P. Abbarno 02/20/2006 Stark E/O Phillips v. Chukwmerjemd, M.D. Defense of medical malpractice wrongful death claim. Defense verdict Thomas A. Prislipsky 02/16/2006 Lucas E/O Miller v. Losey M.D./Defiance Clinic Defense of wrongful death medical malpractice claim. Favorable Result Michael P. Murphy 02/15/2006 Lake Link v. UHHS Defense of wrongful disclosure of medical records. Defense verdict Christine S. Reid 02/14/2006 Lake Penkal v. Jarkewicz, D.O. Defense of medical malpractice colon cancer delayed diagnosis case. Defense verdict Ronald A. Mingus 02/14/2006 10th Appellate Dist. Niermeyer v. Cook's Termite & Pest Control. Inc. Affirming summary judgment in favor of Defendant where Plaintiffs found termite damage after purchasing house but failed to demonstrate justifiable reliance on any misrepresentations of Defendants. Affirmed 02/09/2006 10th Appellate Dist. Shambaugh v. Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. Dismissing Defendants appeal of denial of its motion for reconsideration of summary judgment regarding uninsured motorist coverage since the decision was not a final appealable order. Appeal Dismissed 02/08/2006 Franklin Kester v. A. Brakel M.D. Defense of neurosurgical medical malpractice case. Defense verdict 02/06/2006 7th Appellate Dist Samonas v. St. Elizabeth Health Ctr. Reversing the trial courts grant of summary judgment to Defendants since Plaintiffs complaint adequately set forth a wrongful death claim as to avoid complete dismissal Reversed Holly Marie Wilson 02/03/2006 Hamilton A. Thompson v. I. Washington, M.D. Defense of medical malpractice cancer diagnosis case. Defense verdict Brian D. Goldwasser Thomas B. Kilbane 02/02/2006 8th Appellate Dist. Fisher v. Bill Lake Buick Affirming denial of unemployment benefits to Plaintiff since he quit his job without just cause Affirmed Martin T. Galvin 02/01/2006 Allen K & K Elwer v. Carrol's Corp. dba Burger King Defense of commercial premises liability personal injury claim. Defense verdict Laurie J. Avery 02/01/2006 Fayette County, KY J. Mullins v. Bluegrass Regional Mental Health Retardation Board, Inc., et al. Defense of auto liability personal injury claim. Plaintiff verdict Mark R. Bush Robert W. Hojnoski 01/31/2006 Lucas E/O Bowman v. J. Crisologo M.D. Defense of medical malpractice wrongful death claim involving bowel perforations. Defense verdict Philip S. Heebsh Michael P. Murphy 01/30/2006 Pickway T. Jones v. Marathon Oil Co. Prosecution of commercial real estate easement infringement claim against landowner defendant. Judgment for plaintiff granting removal order Gregory D. Brunton 01/30/2006 Cuyahoga E/O Czarney v. Amherst Hospital Defense of wrongful death hospital malpractice claim. Defense verdict Christine S. Reid 01/25/2006 Muskingham E/O Coey v. Balogh M.D. Defense of psychiatric malpractice wrongful death claim. Favorable Result Warren M. Enders Robert Kish 01/17/2006 Cuyahoga Moyers v. Hansen Arbitration defense of dental malpractice. Finding for Defendant Richard J. Rymond 01/13/2006 Montgomery Vaughn v. Zoeller Pump, Inc. Defense of products liability claim. Defense verdict John Dunn 01/12/2006 Cuyahoga M. Pearl, et al. v. J. Binder Prosecution of plaintiff auto liability personal injury claim. Plaintiff verdict Gregory G. Guice 01/10/2006 Cuyahoga Coleman v. York Arbitration defense of dog bite case. Finding for defense Robert D. Warner Click below for Archived Results: 2010 Results 2009 Results 2008 Results 2007 Results 2005 Results 2004 Results 2003 Results 2003 Results 2002 Results 2001 Results 2000 Results 1999 Results 1998 Results 1997 Results 1996 Results